Halifax
Orchestration
The Music Part I Part II Part III

HANDEL'S JUDAS MACCABAEUS - The "Halifax Orchestration"
William Priestley (left), founder of Halifax Choral Society, does not enjoy widespread fame outside Yorkshire, and Baron Gottfried van Swieten (below right), is not a name that readily springs to Yorkshiremen's lips, either. Yet, the two, who never met, shared a passion for the music of Handel and Mozart, and it is this fortuitous link which may well have benefited both Halifax Choral Society and the whole musical world.

An eighteenth century Viennese nobleman, ambassador to Prussia and patron of the arts, van Swieten was largely responsible for popularizing the music of Handel, and especially the oratorios, among audiences outside of England. It was he who produced German translations of several of the oratorios and commissioned Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart to orchestrate/ arrange a number of them in line with 18th century taste. One such arrangement of Messiah is well known and has enjoyed something of a revival, even attracting the attention of such 'authentic' worthies as Harry Christophers in a recently recorded performance with our neighbours, Huddersfield Choral Society, for the BBC. A number of other arrangements of Handel's oratorios are known to exist, but although there was anecdotal evidence to suggest that Mozart had arranged Judas Maccabaeus, the absence of any extant score led musicologists to believe that no such arrangement had been made.

In June last year, however, Dr Rachel Cowgill was researching for an article about music in Georgian Halifax for the prestigious Early Music publication and chanced upon what appears to be a very important discovery. Among the many music scores bequeathed to Halifax Choral Society by William Priestley was a manuscript score of Handel's Judas Maccabaeus, which, according to its title page, was arranged by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. While the score is not in the hand of Mozart himself, its general style of presentation, and the paper and ink used indicate that it originates from Mozart's time and is probably Austro/German in origin. The additional instrumentation and embellishments of Handel's original found in this manuscript are remarkably similar to those found in Mozart's arrangement of Messiah, of which, incidentally, there are copies in the same collection.

 
Halifax
Orchestration
The Music Part I Part II Part III

Judas Maccabaeus - More about the music
The Manorah - ceremonial candelabra lit at HannukahComposed in 1746, Judas Maccabaeus tells the story of a famous Jewish leader (c 175 BC.) who succeeded his father, Mattathias, in fighting off the armies of Antiochus, the oppressive King of Syria and reestablished religious freedom for the Jews. His final victory is still celebrated at Hanukkah, the "Feast of Lights", which commemorates the restoration and rededication of the temple. Its first performance in April 1747 was hugely successful and received no fewer than 54 performances before Handel's death in 1759, thirty-three of which were conducted by Handel himself. After Messiah, it still continues to be the most frequently performed of his oratorios.The libretto was written by Rev. Thomas Morell to mark the defeat by Prince William, Duke of Cumberland over Bonnie Prince Charlie at Culloden. The printed word book for its first performance bore the following dedication to William: Faint Portraiture of a Truly Wise, Valiant and virtuous Commander.

 

 

 
Halifax
Orchestration
The Music Part I Part II Part III

Judas Maccabaeus - Part I
An elegant French Overture in G minor opens with stately dotted rhythms. Its contrasting fugal section features a repeated semiquaver figure, a characteristic also found in a number of later items, wherever conflict is being suggested. The overture leads almost seamlessly into the Lamentations for the Death of Mattathias which feature two moving (and very different) choruses. Mourn, ye afflicted children has the measured tread of a funeral march, sustaining our involvement with varied choral textures and subtly dramatic harmony. For Sion lamentation make, however, represents much more effusive, perhaps self-indulgent grief, and the addition of sighing bassoons to the orchestra point this up. The falling melody of For Sion lamentation make and the faltering delivery, searing dissonances and dramatic silences of, with words that weep and tears that speak, must surely add up one of Handel's most acutely observed depictions. Simon, Judas' brother, perceiving this mood, appeals to the people's faith and exhorts them to stop mourning and start praying. Handel's answer is equally perceptive: in Pious Orgies, pious airs, a model of balance and restraint, the soprano subtly expresses the people's mixed emotional response. A more wholehearted choral prayer follows in O Father, whose almighty power, in which a serene hymn quickly turns into a much more vehement request at the words, and grant a leader bold and brave.
Judas is chosen as the new leader
Inspired by prayer, Simon identifies Judas as the new leader and launches into, Arm, arm ye brave, a virile call to arms. The chorus responds unequivocally with the equally stirring, We come in bright array. Judas, however, prays that he will be as strong and courageous as his forebears in, Call forth thy powers, my soul, and dare, which Handel aptly set as an exacting coloratura aria, featuring repeated semiquavers in its accompaniment. The Israelitish Woman (soprano) prays a blessing on Judas and, in a welcome contrast to bellicosity, we are reminded that the joy of liberty is the ultimate aim. Not surprisingly, the gracefully melodious, Come ever smiling liberty for soprano voice/s that follow/s attained considerable independent popularity in Handel's lifetime and is still a favourite today.

The momentum for war, justified in Judas' recitatives, continues with two dramatic choruses, Lead on, lead on and Disdainful of danger, the latter once again featuring repeated semiquavers in its accompaniment. Judas balances these outbursts with No unhallowed desire, an aria in which he is at pains to eschew personal ambition and to espouse the cause of peace. His final call to arms is followed by a majestic choral prayer, Hear us O Lord, an object lesson in choral sonorities.

 
Halifax
Orchestration
The Music Part I Part II Part III

Judas Maccabaeus - Part II
The second part begins with the excited chorus, Fall'n is the foe, in celebration of Judas' victories over the armies of Apollonius the Governor of Samaria, and Seron the Deputy Governor of Caelesyria. Handel sustains our excitement with writing of great thematic economy employing two rhythmically contrasting themes and subjecting them to hugely varied treatment: unison voices, imitative counterpoint and strong dynamic contrasts. (The victory is further celebrated and the quest for freedom reiterated in So rapid thy course is. ) In delightful contrast, the gentle duet for sopranos, Sion now her head shall raise, based on a song by Bononcini, extends into an equally lovely five-part chorus Tune your harps. The tranquil mood continues in, From mighty kings he took the spoil, in which the soprano muses over Judas' achievements and with filigree coloratura figurations portrays a delightful impression of joy. The duet and chorus, Hail Judea, happy land! reinforce the same sentiments in a much more ebullient way.
God alone should be thanked . . .
However, Judas warns the people not to congratulate him or themselves: God alone should be thanked for the victory. In a strutting aria How vain is man who boasts in fight Handel's music wryly captures the ineffectual posturings of the braggart. His warnings alas, prove too late, when a messenger arrives to warn them of a renewal of the war by a diversion of the Syrian Army from Egypt, under Gorgias. Crestfallen, the soprano and chorus pour out their grief in the deeply moving Ah! wretched Israel, which features an impassioned cello solo.
Chastisement, not destruction . . .
Simon once more accentuates the positive, suggesting that the purpose of their fate is chastisement, not destruction, and sings a powerful testimony to the Lord in, The Lord worketh wonders. Buoyed up by this, Judas resolves to fight Gorgias and launches into Sound an alarm, an exhilarating call to arms, complete with clarion call and drums. With great dramatic effect, the call is taken up and, without a break, the choral response, We hear, erupts. It begins with great gusto, only briefly comtemplates the possibility of defeat, but then renews its resolve even more stirringly than before.
We worship God and God alone . . .
On behalf of those who remain behind, Simon condemns the way in which the Sanctuary at Jerusalem has been desecrated by idolatry and renews their determination to worship only the God of Israel. With pious hearts, a most moving melody with a beautiful violin counter-melody, is his act of faith. (In the orchestral drone at the words Nor dread the nations that defy us, its first audience may, perhaps, have detected a brief passing reference to Scotland and the Jacobite uprising.) After being warned of the allure of false gods, Wise men, flattering, may deceive you, a stately soprano aria elegantly reinforces the message. An insistent response in the duet and chorus, We never will bow down, bring the section to a close, and when in its final moments the unremitting quaver movement gives way to the chorale-like melody, We worship God and God alone, it does so with stirring dramatic effect.

 
Halifax
Orchestration
The Music Part I Part II Part III

Judas Maccabaeus - Part III
After Judas and his Followers have recovered and restored the Sanctuary, re-establishing liberty and religious freedom, preparations for the Feast of Lights proceed. The tranquil and most beautiful alto aria, Father of heaven, asks God's blessing on the rites, and prayers for peace continue in the recitatives that follow. Celebration begins with an effervescent aria, So shall the lute and harp awake, arguably one of Handel's best, and a wonderful vehicle for vocal display. News arrives of the imminent arrival of Judas, returning from a further victory over Nicanor. His welcome is in the form of the celebrated, See the conquering hero comes, in which first the youths, then the virgins, and finally the whole chorus repeat the fine tune. An equally evocative march concludes the scenario. Alto and tenor solos introduce Sing unto God, a celebratory chorus in the grand Handelian manner. Judas, however, makes time to remember those who died in the conflict, and sings their epitaph in With honour let desert be crown'd, a sober martial tune with trumpet obbligato.
Halleluiah! Amen. . .
A message from the Jewish ambassador to Rome announcing that Rome has guaranteed peace and liberty evokes a grateful response in the fine imitative chorus, To our great God, and the gently swaying duet, O lovely peace. Peace celebrations continue with an ebullient bass aria, Rejoice O Judah!, and its invitation is taken up in the fine celebratory chorus Hallelujah, Amen, which brings the oratorio to a rousing conclusion.

Halifax
Orchestration
The Music Part I Part II Part III
© Copyright J.S.Whitehead 02/2002
Back to the Library?
Return to Concerts Page?